Justifications for 64-bit integer arrays in FITS files

Scientific justifications

The following cases illustrate scientific problems that could require arrays of integer data with more than 32-bits of precision.
  1. Arrays of time measurements where the time is measured as the number of small clock 'ticks' from some reference time (e.g., the start times of a series of binary star eclipses).
  2. Histograms generated from data bases of astronomical sources containing more than 2^32 objects.
  3. Rebinned or summed images from large mosaic CCD cameras that may result in more than 2^32 total counts per binned pixel. Similarly, cumulative histograms of 32-bit integer arrays may exceed 2^32.
  4. Arrays of indices to individual pixels in large images (e.g., a list of bad pixels). The indices could involve non-rectangular pixelizations like HTM or HEALPix so that the total number of pixels matters (they have a 1D index, instead of having separate X and Y coordinate indices).
  5. The precise measurement of time or relative position (using the number of wavelengths of light as the yard stick) in emerging fields such as gravitational wave astronomy and/or interferometry.
  6. Numerical simulations that need more than 32-bits of dynamic range.
  7. Arrays of encryption keys or other numeric codes containing more than 32-bits.

Practical or sociological justifications

The following arguments give various practical reasons for supporting 64-bit integer arrays in FITS files.
  1. The 64-bit integer data type is available in virtually every modern programming language. Programmers will inevitably make use of this datatype (whether or not the added precision is strictly required) and will sometimes want to store the results to a FITS file. Having to convert the values to 32-bit integers or 64-bit floats before writing them to the FITS file adds complexity to the software and can lead to errors and confusion if some of the 64-bit integer values are accidentally truncated.
  2. A large segment of the astronomical research community uses FITS as the on-line analysis format for all types of data files, including temporary and/or intermediate numerical results. When data volume constraints are not an issue, programmers may want to save integer results using the data type with the most range and precision, especially if there is any uncertainty about what precision is actually required.
  3. In order to "future proof" applications it may be prudent to use 64-bit integers even if 32-bit integers seem adequate for current needs. Software applications can end up being used for decades, at which point it could be difficult to retrofit the software to support 64-bit integers.
  4. Most other scientific data formats support the 64-bit integer data type, so FITS suffers by comparison. Scientific research is becoming more interdisciplinary, so it is important to be able to import data files from other fields such as space physics, planetary astronomy, and earth sciences into FITS. This is made more difficult if FITS does not support the same basic data types as the other data formats.
  5. From an abstract "data model" point of view, a primary array or image extension is identical to a table with 1 row and 1 column that contains the image as a vector. Conceptually, one should be able to convert any table vector into a FITS image array. Thus, if 64-bit integers are to be supported in FITS tables, then that data type should logically also be supported in FITS images.
  6. From an implementation point of view, once FITS I/O software have been upgraded to support 64-bit integers in FITS tables, there is very little added cost to support 64-bit integer images (because tables and images are interchangeable, as described in the previous bullet).
  7. "Build it, and they will come": One should not underestimate the ingenuity of users and programmers in finding uses for new features. If 64-bit integer arrays are supported in FITS, users will discover novel applications for them that were not anticipated.
Last revised: Tuesday, 12-Nov-2013 16:55:37 EST
Contact us: fits @ fits.gsfc.nasa.gov
Hosted by: The HEASARC (High Energy Astrophysics Science Archive Research Center)
Responsible NASA representative: Dr. Alan P. Smale
Privacy, Security & Accessibility Statements.